You’re busy with new clothes, gadgets, and crackers galore this festive season. It’s also that auspicious time for you to add to your gold hoarding. But if your intention is ‘investing’ in gold, are you doing it through financial gold or physical gold? What’s the difference?
Physical gold is gold that is tangible and which you can physically hold. That’s your gold jewellery, coins, bars and the like. Financial gold is a financial instrument that derives its value from gold and has gold as the underlying investment. There are several types of financial gold products; the convenient ones among these for the purpose of investment are below.
Gold ETFs
What they are: An ETF (or an Exchange Traded Fund) is an instrument that represents an index or a commodity – in this case, that commodity is gold. To create an ETF, the institution setting it up (usually, they are asset management companies) pools together large sums of money from institutional investors. It uses this money to buy the equivalent in gold bars. It holds this gold in its physical form at warehouses. It then draws up creation units to represent this gold. These creation units are listed on the stock exchange at the prevailing gold price. When you buy these units, you will be effectively investing in gold and when you sell your units, you’re selling your gold. As the gold prices move, the ETF prices moves in tandem. Thus, you get the benefit of buying and selling gold at market prices.
Investment method: You can buy ETFs only on the stock exchanges. Therefore, to invest in gold ETFs, you require a demat and trading account.
Gold funds
What they are: Gold funds are mutual funds that invest in gold ETFs. A gold fund pools in money from investors like you and me, and invests this in gold ETFs. What you buy and redeem are units of the gold mutual fund. Usually, the AMC running the gold fund will invest in the ETF that it is running. For example, SBI Gold Fund will invest in SBI Gold ETF. Gold funds usually have slightly higher expenses than gold ETFs, because they have to account for the costs in continuous deployment of funds and continuous redemption requests. That is, the fund will always have investors putting in and withdrawing their money, which have associated costs. Even so, expense ratios for gold funds are very low at 1% or below.
Investment method: You can invest in a gold fund just as you would with any other mutual fund. You don’t need a demat account; you just need to be KYC-compliant.
Sovereign gold bonds
What they are: The newest form of financial gold, sovereign gold bonds are issued by the Reserve Bank on behalf of the government. These issues are done in batches. The bonds have an 8-year maturity. Each bond represents one gram of gold, and you can buy up to 500 grams in a financial year. Both the purchase price and the redemption price of the bond is the average of the closing gold prices in the preceding five days. In the newest tranche that is opening today (i.e. Oct 24), you will get a discount of Rs 50 on the average price at the time of purchase. Know that the Reserve Bank isn’t going to buy any gold bars or coins or jewellery with your money – its simply giving you a bond whose price is determined by gold prices. Because the bonds have a sovereign guarantee, you run no risks other than the price of gold. The added bonus in sovereign gold bonds is that they pay interest (on the original value of your investment). Up until the latest tranche, this rate was 2.75% per annum. The new issue’s interest rate is 2.5%. This interest, of course, is taxed at your slab rate. You can transfer the bonds before maturity if you so wish. If you hold the bonds in demat form, you can sell it on the exchange. Else, you can exit the bonds on the interest payment dates by communicating your intention before this time (after the fifth year).
Investment method: You can invest in these bonds through your bank, designated post offices, or your broker. You can either hold these bonds in paper form, i.e., you will have a Holding Certificate as proof of your investment, or you can hold them in demat form.
Taxation
Except for sovereign gold bonds, the tax rule for gold in any form – coins, jewellery, bars, ETFs, funds – is the same. Gains on sale attract capital gains tax of 20% with indexation on holding periods of more than 3 years. For holding period less than this, capital gains are taxed at your slab rate.
For gold sovereign bonds, capital gains are tax-free provided you hold the bonds to maturity. If you transfer it before this time, the gains are taxed just like other gold investments.
Financial gold is more suitable for investment purposes than physical gold. One, they are cheaper – no making charges and no wastage! – and you have better price discovery as a result. Two, you don’t have to stress over their storage or possible theft. Three, they are easy to sell and buy. Of course, there is the added relief that you won’t be duped on the purity front!
- Merger of Navi Overnight Fund into Navi Liquid Fund and Navi Conservative Hybrid Fund into Navi Aggressive Hybrid Fund
- Intimation of suspension of subscription in Bandhan US Equity Fund of Fund
Winning Funds, Losing Streaks: Decoding the Mystery of Short-Term Underperformance
Wealth Conversations – November 2024- Notice of Change in Fundamental Attributes of DSP Equity & Bond Fund and DSP Quant Fund
if some one has an equity adn mf exposure, does it make sense to invest in PPF rather than Gold
also is buying silver every month for a 5 year horizon a good option considering its industrial use
Hi Akash,
PPF gives you tax benefits, both when you’re investing (Sec 80C deduction), on the interest and on withdrawal. Gold does not have any tax benefit whatsoever, other than those provided for sovereign gold bonds as we’ve explained in the post. PPF has a long lock-in period and conditional withdrawal before this. PPF is a debt instrument. Because of all this, gold and PPF cannot be compared to each other.
When you say equity exposure, it can be through MFs or directly in stocks. Mutual funds are not a separate asset class. You cannot have equity and MF exposure. What you should see is your equity, debt, and gold exposure. Check where the MFs you have invest, and then arrive at your exposure to each asset class. Gold is a hedge against the other classes and inflation only, and it’s getting more volatile than it used to be. Gold should be at the most 8-10% of your portfolio and not more than that.
Whether or not you should invest in PPF now depends on what your other 80C investments are, what overall debt-equity exposure you have, whether you already have EPF contributions, and your age. You can use PPF as your debt exposure if you don’t mind the long lock-in. But remember that they are low-returning investments (and EPF also). Among 80C investments, ELSS is the highest returning option. So weigh your choices before making 80C investments. On silver, we don’t hold a view.
Thanks,
Bhavana
if some one has an equity adn mf exposure, does it make sense to invest in PPF rather than Gold
also is buying silver every month for a 5 year horizon a good option considering its industrial use
Hi Akash,
PPF gives you tax benefits, both when you’re investing (Sec 80C deduction), on the interest and on withdrawal. Gold does not have any tax benefit whatsoever, other than those provided for sovereign gold bonds as we’ve explained in the post. PPF has a long lock-in period and conditional withdrawal before this. PPF is a debt instrument. Because of all this, gold and PPF cannot be compared to each other.
When you say equity exposure, it can be through MFs or directly in stocks. Mutual funds are not a separate asset class. You cannot have equity and MF exposure. What you should see is your equity, debt, and gold exposure. Check where the MFs you have invest, and then arrive at your exposure to each asset class. Gold is a hedge against the other classes and inflation only, and it’s getting more volatile than it used to be. Gold should be at the most 8-10% of your portfolio and not more than that.
Whether or not you should invest in PPF now depends on what your other 80C investments are, what overall debt-equity exposure you have, whether you already have EPF contributions, and your age. You can use PPF as your debt exposure if you don’t mind the long lock-in. But remember that they are low-returning investments (and EPF also). Among 80C investments, ELSS is the highest returning option. So weigh your choices before making 80C investments. On silver, we don’t hold a view.
Thanks,
Bhavana
Hi ,
How can I invest in E-gold?Is funds india equity supporting through it demat account?
What is benefit E-gold over GOLD ETF?
Hi ,
How can I invest in E-gold?Is funds india equity supporting through it demat account?
What is benefit E-gold over GOLD ETF?