Insights

FundsIndia explains: How do debt funds deliver returns?

May 2, 2016 . Mutual Fund Research Desk

Last week, we covered basics of the types of debt funds. Now, let’s understand how debt funds make their returns. Once that is done, it’s easy to see how risks in debt funds come up and how to manage it.

Capital appreciation
business_talk1Bonds are traded on the market just like equity, though the debt market is nowhere near as liquid and all bonds aren’t listed. Now, a bond carries a specific interest rate or coupon. If interest rates move lower, new debt instruments issued will consequently have lower interest rates. But older instruments that are already issued still carry the old – and higher – interest rate making them more attractive than new instruments. Therefore, their prices move up.

Take, for example, a bond with a face value of Rs 100 and an interest rate of 10 per cent. Then say interest rates moved down and new bonds issued carry an interest rate of 9 per cent. The old bond, in order to bring its yields in line with the new rate, will see its price move up to around Rs 110. If a debt fund holds this bond, it will see its NAV rise as the bond rises. The reverse happens when interest rates go up. Bond prices will move down, in turn lowering debt fund NAV.

Now, the debt fund can sell bonds when prices rally; that is, it gains from capital appreciation of the bond. Such price changes are the most in government bonds as these are the most liquid. When debt fund managers anticipate a downward rate cycle, they usually up holdings of long-term government bonds and make neat gains through capital appreciation. In a static or upward rate cycle, they can move into short-term debt.

The strategy of playing the interest rate cycle is called a duration strategy. Dynamic bond funds (long-term funds) are the ones that typically do this, actively juggling their portfolios between long-term and short-term, corporate or government debt. Gilt funds also follow duration, which is why they work well only when rates fall.

So what’s the risk here? One, these funds have higher volatility as they are driven by bond price changes. Prices react to interest rate changes, potential government borrowing, foreign inflow, and the like. Two, the duration call can take a longer time to play out than expected (this is what has been happening for the past several months, affecting funds following a duration strategy). So if you’re holding such funds, don’t be spooked by volatility in returns.

Income accrual
The second way a debt fund makes its returns is through holding the bonds and accruing the interest due on them. This is called an accrual strategy. They aim at delivering returns across rate cycles and do not bet on directional changes in interest rate as duration funds do or actively trade their debt instruments. Liquid funds, ultra-short term funds, and most short-term funds follow such a strategy. Sometimes, short-term funds may pull a duration play, but they will not get into it as much as long-term dynamic bond funds.

Typically, fund managers will look for bonds that provide them the best yield. Higher-yielding instruments are mostly in corporate debt. When interest rates are moving south – as it is starting to now – it gets harder to have a high portfolio yield. Funds may thus start looking at lower credit-quality companies (recall our explanation on credit risk last week) to generate higher returns.

So what’s the risk here, other than payment delays? A change in the company’s fundamentals can either improve or worsen the credit rating of a company. When the credit rating is lowered, the company will have to pay higher rates if it is to borrow as it becomes riskier. This higher risk perception and the fact that the existing bonds have lower rates results in a mark-down of the bond’s value. The fund’s NAV will thus reduce as the fund adjusts the value of its holding to the new value, or marks it to market as it is officially termed.

This is what happened recently to funds from the Franklin and ICICI stables as steel major JSPL, which was widely held by these two AMCs, was downgraded by rating agencies. When downgrades are steep, as it happened with Amtek Auto last year and JSPL now where the downgrade was 2-3 notches, the mark down in value is greater.

But here’s the important point. The NAV change is a result of fall in bond prices or book value only – it’s notional. The fund may still hold the bond. A credit downgrade does not mean the company has completely defaulted on its payments or even that default is definite. It’s just that the risk has moved up.

If the company continues to pay the interest and principal payment, the fund will recover its entire investment. The loss in NAV due to market price will then neutralise eventually after the bond matures. Unless the fund manager sees a risk of default or further downgrades, such bonds will continue to be held in the portfolio. All you have to do wait it out.

The reverse can also happen; a company can see a credit rating upgrade. Its existing bonds carry higher interest rates and the lower risk perception sends bond prices higher. The fund’s NAV will therefore move up as it marks to market. The fund can book capital appreciation in such cases. Even if the fund held an unlisted instrument, it will enjoy higher coupon in such a bond (as it entered earlier), as fresh issues would come at lower rates. So understand the kind of credit risk you are taking. If you cannot, stick to funds that invest in top-rated debt only, even if you are a long-term investor.

Remember, debt funds, like equity funds, require specific time-frames for investing. If you have a horizon of two years or lower, stick to short-term funds, ultra short-term funds, or liquid funds. Go for long-term debt funds only if your horizon is longer than at least two years.

This brings us to the end of our debt fund discussion. Do let us know if you need anything else explained!

14 thoughts on “FundsIndia explains: How do debt funds deliver returns?

  1. What will be the percentage of debt funds along with equity funds in each portfolio for the long term goals like Retirement, Child education, Marriage.

    For instance all the above goals are more than 15 years + .

    How often the portfolio review should be conducted for the debt funds during this goal period.

    1. Hello,

      For goals over 15 years, around 20-25 percent of your portfolio can be in long-term debt funds. In any long-term investment, you need to keep an eye on the performance every once in a while – say every six months or every year. This goes for your entire portfolio – both equity and debt. Too frequent checks will not help; you will be holding long-term funds. You need to give your investment time to deliver. Looking at daily returns may prevent you from being able to view your investment from a long term perspective. Hope this helps!

      Thanks,
      Bhavana

  2. Hi,

    The article series on debt funds was very informative. I would have liked if you had covered income tax aspects as well.
    My query is related to impact on income tax & how to keep taxes at minimal for various investment options like, investing emergency funds of 4-6 months of someone’s current income, investing for long term like children education & marriage, investing when you are about to retire & investing in debt funds after retirement.
    Please explain with examples for a higher bracket income tax payee (30%) assuming a 9% rate of return of debt funds.
    Probably this itself may call for a separate article in the debt fund series rather a response to this query 🙂

    1. Hi Shashi,

      Thanks! Yes, taxation in debt funds is another large topic 🙂 We’ll do a post on taxation across all funds soon. That should answer your question!

      Bhavana

  3. Pl guide me by giving the names of Debt funds which has given annual rate of return amounting to 11%.
    Similarly we have to pay income tax on this return.Pl giude me giving names of Balanced fund which are giving 11% retuen for last five years.Then I will go for balanced fund having limited risk of equity exposure and I ghink we will not have to pay income tax on divident received by us on balanced fund

    1. Hi Satish,

      Income funds generally give you FD-plus returns. It’s not guaranteed that they will offer 11 per cent returns at all times. Balanced funds will give higher returns than pure debt funds, but please note they are not ‘limited risk’ – the equity exposure is quite high at 75% of their portfolios; the risk much higher than pure debt funds and require holding period of three years at least. Taxation-wise, yes, dividend on balanced funds are not taxed. For fund-specific advice, please log in to your FundsIndia account and book an appointment with your advisor (Help tab feature). We would need more details from you before suggesting funds; we’re also constrained from providing such advice in this forum. This is meant to be for discussion on broad topics.

      Thanks,
      Bhavana

  4. Hi,

    The article series on debt funds was very informative. I would have liked if you had covered income tax aspects as well.
    My query is related to impact on income tax & how to keep taxes at minimal for various investment options like, investing emergency funds of 4-6 months of someone’s current income, investing for long term like children education & marriage, investing when you are about to retire & investing in debt funds after retirement.
    Please explain with examples for a higher bracket income tax payee (30%) assuming a 9% rate of return of debt funds.
    Probably this itself may call for a separate article in the debt fund series rather a response to this query 🙂

  5. What will be the percentage of debt funds along with equity funds in each portfolio for the long term goals like Retirement, Child education, Marriage.

    For instance all the above goals are more than 15 years + .

    How often the portfolio review should be conducted for the debt funds during this goal period.

    1. Hello,

      For goals over 15 years, around 20-25 percent of your portfolio can be in long-term debt funds. In any long-term investment, you need to keep an eye on the performance every once in a while – say every six months or every year. This goes for your entire portfolio – both equity and debt. Too frequent checks will not help; you will be holding long-term funds. You need to give your investment time to deliver. Looking at daily returns may prevent you from being able to view your investment from a long term perspective. Hope this helps!

      Thanks,
      Bhavana

  6. Pl guide me by giving the names of Debt funds which has given annual rate of return amounting to 11%.
    Similarly we have to pay income tax on this return.Pl giude me giving names of Balanced fund which are giving 11% retuen for last five years.Then I will go for balanced fund having limited risk of equity exposure and I ghink we will not have to pay income tax on divident received by us on balanced fund

    1. Hi Satish,

      Income funds generally give you FD-plus returns. It’s not guaranteed that they will offer 11 per cent returns at all times. Balanced funds will give higher returns than pure debt funds, but please note they are not ‘limited risk’ – the equity exposure is quite high at 75% of their portfolios; the risk much higher than pure debt funds and require holding period of three years at least. Taxation-wise, yes, dividend on balanced funds are not taxed. For fund-specific advice, please log in to your FundsIndia account and book an appointment with your advisor (Help tab feature). We would need more details from you before suggesting funds; we’re also constrained from providing such advice in this forum. This is meant to be for discussion on broad topics.

      Thanks,
      Bhavana

  7. Hi,

    The article series on debt funds was very informative. I would have liked if you had covered income tax aspects as well.
    My query is related to impact on income tax & how to keep taxes at minimal for various investment options like, investing emergency funds of 4-6 months of someone’s current income, investing for long term like children education & marriage, investing when you are about to retire & investing in debt funds after retirement.
    Please explain with examples for a higher bracket income tax payee (30%) assuming a 9% rate of return of debt funds.
    Probably this itself may call for a separate article in the debt fund series rather a response to this query 🙂

  8. Hi,

    The article series on debt funds was very informative. I would have liked if you had covered income tax aspects as well.
    My query is related to impact on income tax & how to keep taxes at minimal for various investment options like, investing emergency funds of 4-6 months of someone’s current income, investing for long term like children education & marriage, investing when you are about to retire & investing in debt funds after retirement.
    Please explain with examples for a higher bracket income tax payee (30%) assuming a 9% rate of return of debt funds.
    Probably this itself may call for a separate article in the debt fund series rather a response to this query 🙂

    1. Hi Shashi,

      Thanks! Yes, taxation in debt funds is another large topic 🙂 We’ll do a post on taxation across all funds soon. That should answer your question!

      Bhavana

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

sek