Portfolio Overlapping: How It Happens & How To Avoid It

Portfolio overlap happens when the same or similar assets are held in multiple mutual funds in an investor’s portfolio. Overlapping can result in a lack of diversification and increased exposure to the same risks. Although some degree of overlap is normal, excessive overlap can lead to imbalanced portfolios. Keeping track of mutual fund (MF) overlap, its risks, and how to manage it is essential for creating a well-diversified investment strategy that reduces unnecessary risk and maximizes returns.

What is Mutual Fund Overlap?

Mutual fund overlap occurs when one or more mutual funds in an investor’s portfolio hold the same stocks, bonds, or other securities. For example, if an investor holds shares in a growth fund that holds Apple and a technology fund that also holds Apple, there is an overlap between these funds. Mutual fund overlap is not necessarily bad, but it often results in unintended overexposure to certain sectors, industries, or individual securities if it occurs frequently. This reduces the effectiveness of diversification, which should ideally spread risk across different asset classes. For instance, even if two funds don’t hold the same stocks if both are heavily invested in technology companies (software, hardware, semiconductors), there’s significant sector overlap.

Risks of Mutual Fund Overlap

The main risk of MF overlap is that it undermines diversification. A diversified portfolio spreads investments across different asset classes, sectors, and geographic regions to reduce the impact of a poorly performing investment.

Furthermore, portfolio overlap may lead to higher costs, such as unnecessarily paying for multiple funds with similar holdings, reducing potential returns. Investors may also not realize the full potential of diversification, as the same stocks or sectors may be counted as separate investments, even though they’re highly correlated.

How to Detect Mutual Fund Overlap?

Detecting mutual fund overlap requires careful analysis of your portfolio. Here are several ways to identify overlap:

1. Check the holdings of each fund: Begin by reviewing the holdings for each mutual fund in your portfolio. Most mutual fund companies provide detailed breakdowns of their top holdings in their fact sheets or reports.
   
2. Utilize Portfolio Tracking Tools: Many online tools and platforms help you find mutual fund overlap. These include portfolio analyzers and overlap checkers. These tools analyze your portfolio’s composition and highlight overlapping securities.
   
3. Review Fund Objectives and Strategies: Understand the investment goals of each fund you own. Different mutual funds typically follow different strategies, but if you’ve invested in funds with similar objectives—such as multiple growth funds or large-cap equity funds—there may be more overlap. Compare the fund’s investment objectives to ensure they are distinct.
   
4. Analyze Sector and Industry Exposure: Even if the different funds do not hold the same specific securities, they could still be too concentrated in the same sectors or industries. For instance, multiple funds focused on technology or healthcare could result in sector overlap even though the individual stocks are different.
   
5. Review the Top 10 Holdings: The top 10 holdings of a mutual fund can provide a quick snapshot of potential overlap. Even if a particular security does not appear in multiple funds’ entire holdings, the top 10 holdings often carry the greatest weight in a fund.
   

How to Prevent Overlap in Mutual Funds?

To avoid overlap in mutual funds, start by choosing well-selected funds with complementary strategies and asset allocation. Here are several strategies you can use:

1. Select funds with different objectives: Diversify your investments into funds with various objectives, including growth, value, income, and international exposure. For instance, a value fund and a growth fund can invest in different sectors and securities, minimizing the likelihood of holding the same stocks.
   
2. Invest in Funds with Broad Exposure: Diversify your portfolio by choosing funds that provide broad market exposure, such as index funds or ETFs. These funds, by their nature, track a broad market index and therefore hold a large number of securities across various sectors and regions, minimizing overlap while still offering diversification.
   
3. Limit the Number of Funds in Your Portfolio: Too many funds increase the chances of overlap, especially if they are not closely monitored. Reduce the number of mutual funds you hold, ensuring that each serves a distinct purpose. Consolidating your investments into fewer funds can improve overall diversification.
   
4. Regular Portfolio Review: Market conditions and fund compositions change, leading to gradual increases in overlap. A regular portfolio review and overlap check will enable you to identify imbalances and correct them to ensure proper portfolio balance. Periodic rebalancing ensures that your portfolio aligns with your long-term investment goals.
   

Conclusion

Portfolio overlap is a risk that causes unnecessary concentration in certain assets, reducing diversification and increasing overall risk. Understanding how to detect and avoid mutual fund overlap is crucial for maintaining a well-diversified portfolio. It requires constant monitoring and the use of tools to identify overlap to maintain a balanced portfolio and avoid losses.

FAQs